In one of my previous posts I mentioned a Workplace Ethics Class where lies of omission and commission were discussed and I was reminded of it this morning when I caught myself in a lie. I am going to leave out the details (the internet can be dangerous!), but I’m assuring you that no one was harmed!
Whenever we start learning new things, a language, a game, we always get the “basic rules” taught first. With no precognition, “exceptions” could be overwhelming. But whenever we get more familiar with the basics, comfortable enough to apply them, we start differentiating and opening our mind to exceptions.
As kids, we start acquiring fundamental rules of moral conduct and one of the first lessons is: “Do not lie”. Especially not to mommy and daddy.
But as we grow older, and sometimes even as children, we instinctively feel overpowered by discretion and tactfulness and withhold certain judgments or information. Should I tell her that that dress looks awful on her? Or should I go with a more diplomatic “Sure, you look great!” Can I fake that much enthusiasm? Maybe tone it down a little? Because deep down, we feel it’s not completely right. Even with something trivial, you never know what the consequences of your lies could be. Maybe she’ll wear that dress to her blind date… What will he think?!
I can usually live with lies that won’t harm anyone without feeling too guilty (as in having sleepless nights), for example the “cover your ass”-lies that won’t compromise anyone else (blaming it on “higher forces”, anything that’s out of your control). You might still feel bad because you didn’t live up to someone’s (or your own) expectations, but you don’t feel like you destroyed a cosmic balance.
What about when things get more serious? What if you work in the marketing department and your boss wants you to deliberately deceive your customers? What if you see your friend’s boyfriend walk hand in hand with another girl? What if you cheated on your partner? Would you tell them?
I’ve heard both perspectives. Guys that “pride” themselves because, after all, they confessed they had cheated. Was it liberating? A weight off their shoulders? Yes, because they obviously couldn’t live with it any longer, either because they were too afraid she was going to find out some other way, or maybe even for the “right” reasons. Was she devastated? Certainly. One last question: Were selfish reasons a motive for telling the truth? Well, I must say I might come to that conclusion after talking to guys that will show such pride when stating that they had the “guts” to come clean.
By the way, I’m not excluding women from cheating at all, but no woman has ever told me she cheated on her boyfriend before… they might like to keep that information more private, who knows.
I recently actually talked to a friend who openly admitted she would never want her boyfriend to admit he cheated on her. She’d rather not know anything about it, than having to deal with that kind of pain. Yes, I was shocked to hear her say that.
But do we really always want to know the painful truth? Aren’t we thankful, at times, that people “protect” us from that?
Is there a difference between a husband having a one-night-stand after 15 years of marriage and a girl cheating for weeks on a guy that she had been dating for a year?
I’d say if experience and maturity teach us anything, it’s not to see the world in black and white.
I think it is equally hard to judge and decide if we should hurt someone and how much pain we are willing to deal with.
The honesty of other people, even if hurtful, can (and mostly will) make us learn and grow.
Of course, we should strive to prevent actions that will make us feel guilty. We all know that’s not always possible. But what else would we have a conscience for?